Metal on gearbox metal

Need some help with a technical problem - ask away and let's see if we can all help.

Moderators: hot66, impmad2000, Nige

Post Reply
neilbardsley
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 8635
Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 4:31 pm

Metal on gearbox metal

Post by neilbardsley »

None Porsche related.

Had the gearbox replaced by a local company, with a reconditioned one, in our discovery. Picked up the last day before lockdown in March. Changed the oil and saw this on the magnet? Too much metal surely? I wanted to ask an opinion before I went back to them

Image

Sent from my Redmi 7 using Tapatalk
“A REMINDER. I would be grateful if those members who have borrowed bits from me in emergencies (e.g starter motor, oil cooler, etc) would return them and/or contact me”. – Chris Turner RIP
Gary71
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 10731
Joined: Wed Mar 31, 2004 1:27 pm
Location: Cheshire
Contact:

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by Gary71 »

Did it have any oil in it when you drained it?

No experience of 356 gearboxes and what’s typical for ‘bedding in’, but if it were mine I’d be concerned.
neilbardsley
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 8635
Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 4:31 pm

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by neilbardsley »

Gary71 wrote:Did it have any oil in it when you drained it? Image

No experience of 356 gearboxes and what’s typical for ‘bedding in’, but if it were mine I’d be concerned.
The oil was up to the normal level and it's a R380 gearbox for a Land Rover. I suspect they just change the bearing but there is wear in the gear or syncos!
“A REMINDER. I would be grateful if those members who have borrowed bits from me in emergencies (e.g starter motor, oil cooler, etc) would return them and/or contact me”. – Chris Turner RIP
Lightweight_911
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 17999
Joined: Wed Nov 12, 2003 10:48 pm
Location: Worcs/W Mids border

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by Lightweight_911 »

.

That looks horrendous !!

I'd head straight back to the garage who supplied/fitted it.

Although, they may try to waive any responsibility after ~ 6 months ...

.
Andy

“Adding power makes you faster on the straights;
- subtracting weight makes you faster everywhere”
wildtexas
DDK forever
Posts: 501
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 1:10 am
Location: N. Ireland

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by wildtexas »

Hey Neil,

I think you know the answer don't you? I'd be very concerned to see that much swarf.

Why not post it on some the of the landrover forums to get a response.

I'd be forwarding that photo to the company and politely asking for a response.

Did the box come with a warranty?

Matt
neilbardsley
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 8635
Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 4:31 pm

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by neilbardsley »

I have posted on a lr but I don't think they are out of bed yet.

Called the garage and sent the picture

Sent from my Redmi 7 using Tapatalk
“A REMINDER. I would be grateful if those members who have borrowed bits from me in emergencies (e.g starter motor, oil cooler, etc) would return them and/or contact me”. – Chris Turner RIP
911hillclimber
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 20694
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2008 6:26 pm
Location: West Midlands

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by 911hillclimber »

Terrible sight.
Certainly not right, lots of steel from a box - gears and/or bearings.

A good garage will have that in and sort it. Did you 'measure' the amount of oil that came out as that may indicate the amount they put in.
73T 911 Coupe, road/hillclimber 3.2L
Lola t 492 / 3.2 hillclimb racer
Boxster 987 Gen II 2.9
neilbardsley
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 8635
Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 4:31 pm

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by neilbardsley »

Graham I didn't measure the oil that came out but the oil level was correct. I always undo the fill bolt before draining and oil come out when I undid it

Sent from my Redmi 7 using Tapatalk
“A REMINDER. I would be grateful if those members who have borrowed bits from me in emergencies (e.g starter motor, oil cooler, etc) would return them and/or contact me”. – Chris Turner RIP
neilbardsley
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 8635
Joined: Mon Apr 16, 2012 4:31 pm

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by neilbardsley »

Garage said not to worry. Gearbox settling in. I asked if I checked in 1000-2000 miles it will be better and they replied yes. We are going to Devon this week after we get back I will check again.

Not sure I believe them but ...

Sent from my Redmi 7 using Tapatalk
“A REMINDER. I would be grateful if those members who have borrowed bits from me in emergencies (e.g starter motor, oil cooler, etc) would return them and/or contact me”. – Chris Turner RIP
User avatar
Bootsy
Site admin and the Boss
Posts: 25681
Joined: Sat Nov 08, 2003 6:09 pm
Location: Norwich
Contact:

Re: Metal on gearbox metal

Post by Bootsy »

Similar to when you seek tech support.....

‘Try turning it off and on again’

‘Delete it and reinstall it’

Codswallop
1972 911T | 1994 993 Carrera | 1999 986 Boxster |

Vintage Heuer, Omega, Zenith and other vintage watches - http://www.heuerheritage.co.uk
Post Reply