Instead of the readily available new H4 headlights, I got hold of some genuine H1 headlights. Pretty rare, apparently, and genuine Bosch logo on the glass!
Quite a bit of corrosion to deal with, as one should expect:
Sanded and dissolved the oxide using phosphoric acid mixed with wallpaper paste (to make it thicker). Once that stood for a while, it was all washed off and polished to 3000 grit
FInally repainted with mirror finish paint. It won't be as good as the original reflector, but it'll be way better than it was:

1970 911T, Signal orange (
Restoration thread)
1988 3.2 Carrera backdate, Black
2001 996 Turbo, Lapis blue (am I allowed to put that here?)
I'm looking for a pre-impact bumper 911S or other high-revving 911 to restore - please let me know if you see one.