"Unbalanced" new 356 motor?

Porsche 356 Virtual home

Moderators: 58A - 71E, Helen

sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

"Unbalanced" new 356 motor?

Post by sprintstar67 »

Hello all,
help required to a) put my mind at rest and b) solve an annoying problem!

I picked up the 356C on saturday after waving goodbye to the Speedster :cry: and let me tell you it is a revelation in comparison, apart from the spongy brakes which clearly need bleeding, the car drives great, looks great and feels really tight.
However the more I drive it I can't help feeling the engine feels "unbalanced" as there is a little too much vibration under load. When its idling it does tick over lovely and there are no untoward noises internally.
The engine has just been rebuilt by Strasse of Leeds, so I'm sure its can't be something major and at the moment I'm putting it down to the worn carbs being incorrectly balanced so in effect one side is firing stronger than the other? Would the relevant "experts" on here agree?, Secondary to that I thought the clutch could be misaligned?
Any thoughts and/or theories gladly received, as its the only thing spoiling my new car experience!

Cheers, Andy
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
912uk
Nurse, I think I need some assistance
Posts: 5954
Joined: Wed Nov 12, 2003 11:02 pm

Post by 912uk »

well I would have the carbs looked at or try and balance they your self..

have you checked the acclerator jets all work when you put your foot down?
Linkage check that it's adjusted correctly eg it pulls both carbs evenly..I use a straw with a cocktail stick though the top to stop it falling though and I mark the straw with a perninant marker and just slightly move the trottle and look to see they are moving the same each side..

then check the air flow with a meter..

It's taken a while to learn all this.. but my car is running as smooth as it has ever done

after that.. hmm would need to see it really but could be at the other end of the scale a unbalanced flywheel to the crank..

lets start with basics.....
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

Yeah, I'm leaning toward the carbs being unbalanced. I know they really need reconditioning, as the guy who set them up for the previous owner is a good friend of mine (who looks after several classic grand prix cars) and said he had literally 'done his best' with them.

So I think I'll start with getting them done.....anyone got any recommendations for where to get them done?

Also anyone got any other theories I can check, as I'm pulling the motor out anyway?

Cheers, Andy.
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
Helen
Events Organiser
Posts: 5519
Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2004 8:55 pm
Location: Cumbria

Post by Helen »

i am presuming all the engine mounting bolts were done up tight when the engine was put back in and then checked again after a few 100 miles.
cubist
The Fenland Feltcher
Posts: 4044
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:48 pm

Post by cubist »

Check the front box mounts, shifter end... i had a soft one which eventually sheared and caused some horrendous vibration. Before it sheared the vibtration was really only felt at foot off from higher speeds - until it sheared completely becoming a wobbly, gear throwing, tempremental bastid to drive!
C U B I S T - 1 1 1 5

'83 Triumph Acclaim - 3sp Auto (cat D)
Singer 3232 - Titanium bobbin, Autothread
'67 Gresham Flyer - Puncture, rear
Sherbet Lemons - 4oz, loose
Motorola - PG 2000, locked
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

hmmm interesting theories.....all of which I'll check! Only had the car two days, so I'm still finding all the niggly little issues
Still a great car though, although not perfect (which is a good thing!) Its just right.......apart from the vibration!
Interestingly I had also suspected the gearbox mounts as the cabin noise is also more than usual, but the engine sounds fine and quiet from the outside
hmmmm much to think on!
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
Mike Smith
DDK rules my life!
Posts: 1243
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2005 12:37 am
Location: Billericay, Essex
Contact:

Engine Vibration

Post by Mike Smith »

Exhaust or any part attached to the engine - Touching the Body / Bumpers

Mike at PR
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

I think the key here is to pull the motor, check (replace) the gearbox mounts, check and re-align the clutch for peace of mind, then put everything back correctly as I've got a feeling the exhaust is touching the rear bumper too.
Stick it back in and see if it makes any difference.
Carbs really need a rebuild, so they'll get done as matter of course over the winter anyway.

I know what I'll be doing tonight then!
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

Theres now some suggestion (from a reputable source) that it could be the cam timing?
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
rocket280
DDK above all
Posts: 150
Joined: Fri Apr 29, 2005 10:16 pm
Location: watford

Post by rocket280 »

How can the cam timing go out of adjustment. The cam is bolted to the cam gear which drives off of the crank. if the cam gear was worn to the limit and it had loads of back lash I still don't think this would alter the cam timing that much. do you think he means the tappets need adjusting. I don't understand. Are you sure he knows what he is talking about. Maybe someone else can shed some light on it.
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

Because the engines just been rebuilt, it could have been misaligned during reassembly? Thats what he was suggesting.....but I have the simple things to go through first!
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
Graham
DDK forever
Posts: 561
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2004 12:56 am
Location: Northern tip of dartmoors rocky wilderness

Post by Graham »

The cam gera can go on one of 3 ways, one is correct the other two it wont run at all!
1985 MZ Simson/KH 125 Sprint bike
1302s one family owner
1963 AMC 660 Classic
1957 Peugeot TC4 race bike


Sadly gone:
74' 914/4 2.0
68' SWB 911
sprintstar67
DDK above all
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2004 2:11 pm
Location: littleborough, lancs

Post by sprintstar67 »

This is all specualtion anyway at this point, and hopefully it'll be nothing, but I think he meant it could be out by a tooth or two......which I find hard to believe from a reputable outfit.
'62 Bug Karmann Cabrio (the GCC car)
'67 Bug
'99 Mexican Bug
'67 Split Crew Cab
'76 MGB Roadster
'90 MX5
'79 911 SC Targa
'72 Fiat 124 Spider
'73 Eriba Familia
'03 Chesil Speedster
'03 BMW 330D Touring
'97 Disco
rocket280
DDK above all
Posts: 150
Joined: Fri Apr 29, 2005 10:16 pm
Location: watford

Post by rocket280 »

I doubt if it would run at all if it was out by a tooth or 2 the valves may even hit the tops of the pistons. one way to be sure is to remove the front part of the case then you will see if the alinghing marks line up or not. you could even do this with the engine in the car and sort it out if it needs it. but I very much doubt this is your problem
Graham
DDK forever
Posts: 561
Joined: Sun Aug 01, 2004 12:56 am
Location: Northern tip of dartmoors rocky wilderness

Post by Graham »

rocket280 wrote:I doubt if it would run at all if it was out by a tooth or 2 the valves may even hit the tops of the pistons. one way to be sure is to remove the front part of the case then you will see if the alinghing marks line up or not. you could even do this with the engine in the car and sort it out if it needs it. but I very much doubt this is your problem
Agreed,especially as it ticks over well,maybe throttle rods opening carbs unevenly?
1985 MZ Simson/KH 125 Sprint bike
1302s one family owner
1963 AMC 660 Classic
1957 Peugeot TC4 race bike


Sadly gone:
74' 914/4 2.0
68' SWB 911
Post Reply