Porsche ranked least reliable car

[964RS]

Just sharing article from today.

Thought some may find it interesting.

I’ve certainly found model 996 onwards to be very expensive to maintain if you actually drive them all year round.

https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/car ... RF6eM0IJVk

[911hillclimber]

Experience of my Boxster would underline this article to be true indeed.
So many things poorly designed and hence fail early.
A/C rads (corrosion), water cooling pips (corrosion) switches (tiny contacts), discs (corrosion on inner faces)

Many of these faults are not cheap to DIY or OPC repair, and good indie's costs are not too far behind OPC either. Poor material selection (galvanic corrosion) and lack of surface protection be it simple shields against salt water splash or grit rash etc.

Latest for me is a broken window regulator due to window icing/internals icing at zero Deg C.
Why was this not fixed during product development? (although AUDI TT's suffer too, but my Subaru Impreza was fine)

I know a few with these modern Porsches and non have a lot of good to say about running them.

[Gary71]

Latest for me is a broken window regulator due to window icing/internals icing at zero Deg C.
Why was this not fixed during product development?

Short drop windows are the worst for it as they are repeatedly used in the same area of the gear/cable and then glass freezes to the outer waist seal and overloads the already worn (and probably corroded) cable before the thermal cut out kicks in.

We now test that frozen condition as well as super hot/cold, can’t speak for Porsche though as they tend to do their own thing

Ultimately the window lifts on short drop cars are at best considered a service item…

My wife’s TT:

[Hugo 356]

I’ve certainly found model 996 onwards to be very expensive to maintain if you actually drive them all year round.

Interesting that Porsche brought Toyota consultants in for the 996 to introduce Kaizen. Toyota came second in the same ranking (to Honda)...

[markm]

How can that be the case if people don't keep their modern porsches for more than 2 weeks and only drive them 100 miles before re-selling them

[hot66]

my spyder had its belt tensioner fail

we've replaced the gear shift cables and guides with new and updated ( preventitive ) as they are known to fail

keeping an eye on the front x over pipes

wonder how yellow cars faired in the survey ?

[Mike Smith]

It has been no different since 1948

You have to want to love the cars

[DustyM]

I haven’t read it but has this been biased by all the issues with the Taycan?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[911hillclimber]

Been quoted £350 to do my door problem by a trusted Indie. Part is £100 from Design 911 so might be cheaper at the local OPC(!)

Hope the weather warms up soon so can DIY as the car has to be fixed outside, garage very full. Worth it to keep £200, wife may allow it though!!

Take your point Gary on localised wear n tear.
Boxster has now done 74,000 and I've been waiting for another 'task' as it has been running so very well, knew it couldn't go one!

[hot66]

I haven’t read it but has this been biased by all the issues with the Taycan?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

From the article :

"The data represents only cars that are outside their manufacturer warranties, meaning the minimum age for the sample is three years. The maximum age for cars included in the analysis is 10 years."

[Gary71]

Been quoted £350 to do my door problem by a trusted Indie. Part is £100 from Design 911 so might be cheaper at the local OPC(!)

Hope the weather warms up soon so can DIY as the car has to be fixed outside, garage very full. Worth it to keep £200, wife may allow it though!!

Take your point Gary on localised wear n tear.
Boxster has now done 74,000 and I've been waiting for another 'task' as it has been running so very well, knew it couldn't go one!

If you do DIY then once you’ve got the new lifter back in, get in the car, ignition on, wind the window down fully, shut the door then hold the switch down for a few seconds, then wind it all the way up, hold it again and it should remember it’s end stops and start working again with the one shot.

[911hillclimber]

Yes, read about that today, but thanks for the info.
Tricks everywhere!

[sladey]

I haven’t read it but has this been biased by all the issues with the Taycan?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I was due to have my gt4 serviced next week but it’s been put back to feb because they have so many issues with recovered Taycans - they are clearing all services from the diary next week

[Nine One One]

What issues are the Taycans suffering is it cold wether related?

[Ashley James]

My ex Dem 718 was a nightmare. Turbo failed, heater fan failed (VW problem for years) battery failed, stone chips all down each side in a year. Porsche didn’t fit a protective coating, software stopped demisting of driver’s side window, indicator switch failed etc. I got so fed up with it I went back to Merc and traded it for C300 AMG Cabriolet.

I’ve had three C class and two problems. Wrongly adjusted micro switch kept bonnet light open on and a failed chip stopped passenger window opening.

I bought a 10 year old, 15,000 mile 981S in perfect condition and I’ve done 1500 miles. It’s a lovely car, doesn’t handle or go as well as a 2L 718, but engine is quieter, adaptive suspension better and multi adjustable seat too.

So far the engine mounts failed, £2,500, battery failed £168 (not OEM but longer guarantee), heater fan stopped, works if prodded, but about £900 if replaced by Porsche and a service £900.

Merc on Service agreement £35 per month and 4 new tyres. Similar mileage to both late Boxsters.

The 987 had many more problems by 58,000.

As I understand it, anything pre 981/991 has lots of expensive issues because they’re not as well corrosion protected, because of bore scoring and IMS issues.

I love the 981, but I’m apprehensive of future issues. VW is ailing, propped up by government and $193 billion in debt, overweight management expenses etc, Porsche and Ducati are for sale etc.

I believe Mercedes might be the only really successful German company in the top 20 world’s most valuable and it shows. The endless arrival of new or advanced technology etc. A 2 litre 4 giving 470bhp in the new S Class for example.