Why all the B hating...
Why all the B hating...
... on Bringatrailer? I should perhaps ask them! This is a good example:
https://bringatrailer.com/listing/1961-porsche-356b-3/
The car wasn't billed as anything that it wasn't. Unclear where the reserve was but looked like a solid motor and I can't really understand the level of nitpicking and abuse it got. That's a different question though.
I always thought the T5B was as good looking (if not a little better ) than the C... Personal preference but its interesting to see people talking the T5 down.
Phil
https://bringatrailer.com/listing/1961-porsche-356b-3/
The car wasn't billed as anything that it wasn't. Unclear where the reserve was but looked like a solid motor and I can't really understand the level of nitpicking and abuse it got. That's a different question though.
I always thought the T5B was as good looking (if not a little better ) than the C... Personal preference but its interesting to see people talking the T5 down.
Phil
Phil
1960 356B Silver
1960 356B Silver
-
- Put a fork in me, I'm done!
- Posts: 1653
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2016 3:30 pm
- Location: Near Stroud, Glos. UK
- Contact:
Re: Why all the B hating...
Seems to me that whenever cars appear on the market, various board members set about rubbishing them and crabbing the price. You rarely ever see anything positive.
Cars are worth what they sell for, which will be for quite a bit less now until the spring.
Cars are worth what they sell for, which will be for quite a bit less now until the spring.
Re: Why all the B hating...
Phil: If you read what is written about other cars on BAT, I think you'll find that it relates less to the specific car than to the instant comment ability the internet offers.
Allow me to use the analogy that it is best not to get opinions on race horses from wheat farmers. Comments from people qualified only by the ownership of an email address have only throw-away value.
Allow me to use the analogy that it is best not to get opinions on race horses from wheat farmers. Comments from people qualified only by the ownership of an email address have only throw-away value.
356 Registry member #15,
'65 C Cab., '55 Pre-A coupe
'65 C Cab., '55 Pre-A coupe
Re: Why all the B hating...
True, the anonymity allows people to let loose when they might otherwise not. I'll try not to be a snowflake!!
Phil
1960 356B Silver
1960 356B Silver
-
- Put a fork in me, I'm done!
- Posts: 1816
- Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:41 pm
- Location: Worcestershire
- Contact:
Re: Why all the B hating...
Ah, at last another T5 enthusiast, you are not alone, people were astonished that i went looking for a T5B when i started looking. IMHO the best all round combination, but hey, each to their own. W
Winston
'61 356 BT5 & a lot of broken chain driven stuff
'61 356 BT5 & a lot of broken chain driven stuff
-
- DDK slapper chatter
- Posts: 430
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2010 8:56 am
- Location: www.early911.se
Re: Why all the B hating...
I have never understood the "C" hype..
Seems like a lot of people test drive bad examples of whatever model and start picking on them, often bad mouthing "old technique" like the drum brakes...
Personally, I prefer an A but a T5B is a close second!
Seems like a lot of people test drive bad examples of whatever model and start picking on them, often bad mouthing "old technique" like the drum brakes...
Personally, I prefer an A but a T5B is a close second!
Porsche 911, 1977
DP-Zirkelbach
3L 930/10
Indischrot
Porsche 911, 1971
2.5L Street Beater
Silver metallic
DP-Zirkelbach
3L 930/10
Indischrot
Porsche 911, 1971
2.5L Street Beater
Silver metallic
-
- Put a fork in me, I'm done!
- Posts: 1653
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2016 3:30 pm
- Location: Near Stroud, Glos. UK
- Contact:
Re: Why all the B hating...
Ive got a C, I wasn’t aware of any hype around the model, but it is very good driving and comparatively fast car for 1964. I really like it. Unbelievable that it was £500 more than an E Type in the day until you remember that a Citroen Safari was more expensive than any of the Jags till we voted for the “Common Market”.
-
- Put a fork in me, I'm done!
- Posts: 1816
- Joined: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:41 pm
- Location: Worcestershire
- Contact:
Re: Why all the B hating...
It'll be interesting if the T5 haters attack this one too.....
https://bringatrailer.com/listing/1961- ... 2017-10-14
W
https://bringatrailer.com/listing/1961- ... 2017-10-14
W
Winston
'61 356 BT5 & a lot of broken chain driven stuff
'61 356 BT5 & a lot of broken chain driven stuff
- Hendrik Moulds
- Put a fork in me, I'm done!
- Posts: 1653
- Joined: Tue Oct 24, 2006 10:28 am
- Location: Burley In Wharfedale, West Yorkshire
Re: Why all the B hating...
Count me in as another T5 fan, note I sold my A and not the T5 a couple of years ago.
The drum brakes are perfectly fine when properly looked after, but I'm not sure what people think a 50 plus year old car is supposed to drive like.
There's definitely hype around the C, probably because it's the last of the line and perceived as the most developed and the T5 is the most common so maybe more easily dismissed on those grounds?
The drum brakes are perfectly fine when properly looked after, but I'm not sure what people think a 50 plus year old car is supposed to drive like.
There's definitely hype around the C, probably because it's the last of the line and perceived as the most developed and the T5 is the most common so maybe more easily dismissed on those grounds?
(Formally 356ist)
Membership #: 356!
1953 Cabriolet
1959 Coupe (Sold)
1961 Notchback
1961 Sunroof Coupe (Sold)
1962 Coupe (Gone, but not forgotten!)
ALL RHD OF COURSE!
Membership #: 356!
1953 Cabriolet
1959 Coupe (Sold)
1961 Notchback
1961 Sunroof Coupe (Sold)
1962 Coupe (Gone, but not forgotten!)
ALL RHD OF COURSE!
-
- DDK above all
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Sat Jul 20, 2013 10:15 pm
- Location: Sunshine Coast, Australia
Re: Why all the B hating...
I have always liked the BT6. Properly set up the brakes are fine and the dash looks great. I like the larger glass area at the rear and in a hot climate, the 1/4 vents are so valuable. Paradoxically, in Australia it is one of the least common. Only 44 where sold here in RHD (4 of those to New Zealand), according to our records here.
Merv
Australia
Porsche 356 BT6 (1 of 44 Australian delivered)
Australia
Porsche 356 BT6 (1 of 44 Australian delivered)
Re: Why all the B hating...
I like 'em all. They're all old porsches. I bought a T5B nearly 10years back now because I had always wanted a 356 and I liked the rusty luggage rack on the back of it...and I could afford it. I'm more than happy with it - it's got 1/4 lights in the doors! What I do know (cause I looked at Hagerty's valuations last week) is that a T5b is worth half what the previous year's A is worth. Bargain?
Re: Why all the B hating...
the T5's now seem far more rare than the T6, as they were seen as the runt of the family so presumably suffered more attrition....all the road tests regarded the C as an improvement on the T5 owing mainly to the rear suspension alterations and the disc brakes but at least my T5 will be far less common than all the T6's and A's at shows....and, yes, it was all i could afford as well
Adrian Rendle
-
- DDK above all
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Sat Jul 20, 2013 10:15 pm
- Location: Sunshine Coast, Australia
Re: Why all the B hating...
And it varied from country to country Adrian. In Australia and NZ, the RHD T5 sold more than twice the numbers sold of the T6. Many reasons, mostly economic conditions at the time.
Merv
Australia
Porsche 356 BT6 (1 of 44 Australian delivered)
Australia
Porsche 356 BT6 (1 of 44 Australian delivered)
-
- Married to the DDK
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Tue Oct 06, 2009 11:38 pm
- Location: Essex, UK
Re: Why all the B hating...
The round bonnet does it for me...
Phil Parry
Essex, UK
1972 VW Camper (unrestored original low mileage)
1954 53 model pre-A 1500S in Adria Blue
1957 speedster in Acquamarine Blue
Been and gone:
1960 B Coupe, now in Scotland
1964, 1954, 1949 VW Beetles
Essex, UK
1972 VW Camper (unrestored original low mileage)
1954 53 model pre-A 1500S in Adria Blue
1957 speedster in Acquamarine Blue
Been and gone:
1960 B Coupe, now in Scotland
1964, 1954, 1949 VW Beetles
-
- DDK rules my life!
- Posts: 1230
- Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2005 12:37 am
- Location: Billericay, Essex
- Contact: