1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

A place for Impact Bumpers, 964 and 993 content

Moderators: hot66, impmad2000, Barry, Viv_Surby, Derek, Mike Usiskin

Post Reply
Magnum
DDK slapper chatter
Posts: 471
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 4:29 pm
Location: Cape Town, South Africa

1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

Post by Magnum »

Hi All

How disappointing!

Whilst basking in the glory of the transformed gear change (after shifter bushes replaced etc.) I absent mindedly stalled the car whilst in gear - i.e. whilst stopped with foot on brakes I let out clutch with car in gear, stalling the car :oops: . There is now a single mechanical clunk (and maybe coupled with some driveline lash) when changing gear, taking up drive or decelerating quickly - especially noticeable in first or second gear and in all but the gentlest releasing of the clutch. Appears to drive fine when underway otherwise with no noises etc. There may have been clutch smell or I might just have imagined it in my gutted nervousness.....

Car is too hot to get underneath but hoping it's simply gearbox mounts (which needed doing in any event) but could be actual gearbox, broken clutch center springs (or rubber I understand was original) or CV joints?

Any help in identifying which of these it is - I'm going to jack car up and turn wheels in and out of gear...

UPDATE: Jacked the car up and:

When out of gear - rear wheels spin fine with no clunks, noise etc.

When in gear - rear wheels still spin freely with the transmission turning (how do the rear wheels spin if in gear - thought the engine would have to turn) and there is noticeable lash but then no gearbox noise once the transmission is turning....Clutch?
Magnus

1972 3.2 RS lightweight. Still a bit scary...
1987 3.2 Carrera. Sold..
1972 Alfa 1750 GTV. Sold...
1971 911E in Silver. So lovely, sold..
1971 911S. sold....
1972 BMW CSL. Stupidly sold...
1968 Land Rover SIIa SWB..rusted in half...
kitesurfer2
DDK forever
Posts: 608
Joined: Sun Dec 06, 2009 6:46 pm
Location: cornwall
Contact:

Re: 1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

Post by kitesurfer2 »

Does the gearstick move up and down when you accelerate and decelerate?-If so maybe gearbox mounts are knackered?
Magnum
DDK slapper chatter
Posts: 471
Joined: Tue Apr 08, 2008 4:29 pm
Location: Cape Town, South Africa

Re: 1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

Post by Magnum »

No - it doesn't! I can say with confidence as I know the symptoms you are referring to and have dealt with similar through replacing all the mounts on my early car.

The car is at 80,000 miles so thinking the rubber clutch center (assuming its original factory) has let go which it apparently tends to do at this mileage. After much research I understand that the rubber centered clutches have a fail-safe or get home feature which results in clunking as you engage it? This may also may account for some smell if some rubber bits got stuck in-between clutch and flywheel?

Seriously can't understand why you can spin the rear wheels when jacked up in gear though....and still drive the car? Maybe the fail safe/get home feature only locks under drive?

Thanks for the feedback!
Magnus

1972 3.2 RS lightweight. Still a bit scary...
1987 3.2 Carrera. Sold..
1972 Alfa 1750 GTV. Sold...
1971 911E in Silver. So lovely, sold..
1971 911S. sold....
1972 BMW CSL. Stupidly sold...
1968 Land Rover SIIa SWB..rusted in half...
Berny
Put a fork in me, I'm done!
Posts: 1647
Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2003 9:58 pm
Location: Suffolk
Contact:

Re: 1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

Post by Berny »

Hi Magnus you will be able to turn a rear wheel with the back jacked up unless you have a limited slip diff if in gear the other side will turn backwards.
1971 Targa Sportomatic in Green 1972 2.4e sunroof coupe 1990 964 C2 Member no 82
andytat
DDK forever
Posts: 574
Joined: Sat Jan 14, 2012 2:26 pm
Location: Worcestershire

Re: 1987 Carrera - New mini-crisis - Opinion sought

Post by andytat »

Magnus.

When stalling the car in gear it may have ripped the rubber damper
which is in the centre of the friction lining. G50 and 930 gearboxes
don't have a sprung centred friction plate, they use a large rubber
damper instead. If this is quite old it won't be as strong as it was
and could quite easily fail under sever duress. When they fail there
is a lot of backlash in the transmission when, either releasing the
power or applying it. Unfortunately this will mean a new friction plate.

Regards.

Andy
Now Porsche less and sad.
3.2 Carrera Speedster (Sold and sorely missed)
3.2 Manual Cayenne (Sold)
73 2.4S (Gone to Singapore)
75 3.0l 914 (Sold)
Post Reply